The Morning Dispatch: Biden Rebukes Trump’s Response to Protests and Rioting

Plus, who might replace Shinzo Abe?

Happy Tuesday! On this day 81 years ago, Germany invaded Poland, sparking the conflict that would eventually become known as World War II. A reminder that, as difficult as 2020 has been—for a whole host of reasons—humanity has overcome tremendous hardship and suffering before. Now onto the news.

A reminder: This is the version of TMD available to non-paying readers. We’re happy you’ve made The Dispatch part of your morning routine, and we hope you’re enjoying The Morning Dispatch and the rest of our free editorial offerings. If you do, we hope you’ll consider joining us as a paying member. In addition to the full version of TMD each day, you’ll get extra editions of French Press, the G-FileVital Interests, our campaign newsletter The Sweep, and our other paid products. And members can engage with the authors and with one another in the discussion threads at the end of each of our articles and newsletters. If this appeals to you, we hope you’ll please join now.

Quick Hits: Today’s Top Stories

  • The United States confirmed 33,762 new cases of COVID-19 yesterday, with 4.8 percent of the 701,198 tests reported coming back positive. An additional 534 deaths were attributed to the virus on Monday, bringing the pandemic’s American death toll to 183,579.

  • The D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled 8-2 against former National Security Adviser Michael Flynn’s petition to have District Judge Emmet Sullivan drop his criminal case immediately, as requested by the Justice Department.
  • A day after Rep. Steve Scalise took down and removed a portion of an advertisement after it was revealed to feature doctored audio from a Democratic activist with ALS, White House staff and the Trump campaign shared two videos of Joe Biden that were manipulated, and eventually flagged by social media companies.
  • Facebook said on Monday it would block Australian users from sharing news on its platform if the country passes a law forcing tech companies to pay publishers to distribute their content.
  • Longtime Georgetown University basketball coach John Thompson Jr.—who led the Hoyas to three Final Fours in the 1980s, including a national title in 1984—died on Sunday at the age of 78.

Biden’s Broadside Against Trump

In the week since police shot Jacob Blake in Kenosha, the presidential campaign has been dominated by the riots, looting, and violence that has ensued. Burning buildings and shattered storefronts have served as cable news backdrops for days on end, with the violent clash between anarchists and pro-Trump activists in Portland we discussed yesterday bookending the week. President Trump—and his campaign—used the Republican National Convention to make the case that Joe Biden is aligned with this chaos and unrest. “The hard truth is you will not be safe in Joe Biden’s America,” Vice President Pence said on Wednesday.

Biden worked to rebut such accusations, denouncing street violence, as he had earlier in the summer—first through a spokeswoman, then in a recorded video. On Sunday, he issued a statement condemning “violence of every kind by anyone, whether on the left or the right.” Yesterday, he traveled to a former steel factory in Pittsburgh and tried to flip the script on the incumbent.

“These are not images from some imagined ‘Joe Biden America’ in the future,” he said, referencing the unrest around the country. “These are images from Donald Trump’s America today. He keeps telling you if only he was president it wouldn’t happen. … He keeps telling us if he was president you’d feel safe. Well he is president, whether he knows it or not. And it is happening. It’s getting worse.”

Who Will Replace Shinzo Abe?

Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe announced his resignation last week, citing his worsening health due to bowel disease. Abe served four terms in the role—from 2006 to 2007, and from 2012 to 2020—and just last year became the longest-serving prime minister in Japan’s history. He will remain in office until September 17, around which point his successor as leader of the Liberal Democratic party will be chosen.

The party announced next month’s election will be a streamlined version of the usual selection process, with rank-and-file members and “friends of the party” excluded from the voting. The simplified process will help the government maintain continuity in its response to the COVID-19 crisis, as well as avoid a drawn out leadership struggle that could threaten the Party’s majority.

Campaigning (at least in a smoke-filled-room kind of manner) for the position has already begun. Japanese media reported Sunday that Yoshihide Suga, Abe’s chief cabinet secretary and right-hand man, is looking to replace his boss. Other contenders include Shigeru Ishiba, a former minister of defense and political rival of Abe, who has long advocated for a buildup in Japan’s military capabilities, and Fumio Kishida, an Abe ally and former minister for foreign affairs.

A Different Debate Over COVID Testing

There’s an unexpected new fight developing in the COVID-19 testing world. Not the same political fight we’ve already seen dozens of times about whether we’re testing enough (or too much!), but a fight over the tests themselves, and whether they might be—of all things—too sensitive to the presence of the virus. Andrew has the details over at the site today. Finding out whether a test is positive, for example:

… requires an elaborate laboratory process—a process that’s predicated on at least one injection of human subjectivity. The tests in ubiquitous use around the country make use of a process called polymerase chain reaction, which rapidly multiplies viral RNA in a sample to bring it to a measurable level. It’s a time-tested, proven process.

But it isn’t a one-step process: the PCR process must be cycled multiple times to get the virus to that level of visibility. How many cycles are necessary varies from test to test, but the math of exponential multiplication means that the more virus-saturated a sample was to begin with, the fewer you’ll need before you see the results.

The trouble—perhaps—involves how many times a test is cycled before it can be declared negative: up to either 37 or 40 cycles for COVID tests. In a New York Times article published over the weekend, a number of epidemiologists said they were concerned that number of cycles was too high: enough to return a positive result even when truly miniscule amounts of the virus are present in the initial sample, “akin to finding a hair in a room long after a person has left.”

Others disagree.

“I get very concerned about making very sweeping statements about infectivity compared to CT value,” Dr. Susan Butler-Wu, a pathology professor and clinical microbiologist at USC, told The Dispatch. “These are specimens that are obtained from the upper respiratory tract. … And we know that over the course of time the virus actually transitions from being in your upper respiratory tract down into the lower respiratory tract, or your lungs. So I don’t think there’s really a whole lot of evidence at all to say that we know for sure that a high CT value means you’re definitely not infectious.”

Worth Your Time

  • Ideological and cultural sorting are at such high levels nowadays that knowing someone’s political affiliation is, oftentimes, akin to knowing their taste in music or clothes or cuisine, what TV shows they watch, how they worship, even their coronavirus risk tolerance. This, Kit Wilson argues in a terrific piece for Arc Digital, is why culture wars ruin everything. “There is no rule woven into the universe that states that some specific opinion somebody holds must inevitably be linked with some other specific opinion, like atoms that are only configurable into a limited number of molecular combinations,” he writes. “We live at a moment in history when the cross-pollination of interesting ideas, from all sorts of backgrounds, ought to be easier than ever — when pop culture fanatics and post-liberals, high artists and hipsters, religious conservatives and radicals should be able to learn from one another in a spirit of shared humanity. And we’re wasting it on petty, small-minded squabbles.”
  • Amy Walter—former Remnant guest—consistently puts out some of the smartest election analysis there is. Her most recent piece evaluating the state of the race headed into the home stretch is no exception. “While many are looking for signs that Trump is filling in cracks in his base, Trump’s real problem is much deeper,” she writes. “Trump is trailing, not because he’s losing his 2016 base, but because he has never expanded beyond it.”

Presented Without Comment

Reporting by Declan Garvey (@declanpgarvey), Andrew Egger (@EggerDC), Charlotte Lawson (@charlotteUVA), Audrey Fahlberg (@FahlOutBerg), James P. Sutton (@jamespsuttonsf), and Steve Hayes (@stephenfhayes).

Photograph by Alex Wong/Getty Images.