The Morning Dispatch: Supreme Court Rules on Trump’s Financial Records

Plus, the GOP’s QAnon problem.

Happy Friday! And good morning to all of our eastern Oklahoma readers who found out yesterday they’ve been living a lie. Boomer Sooner!

A reminder: This is the version of TMD available to non-paying readers. We’re happy you’ve made The Dispatch part of your morning routine, and we hope you’re enjoying The Morning Dispatch and the rest of our free editorial offerings. If you do, we hope you’ll consider joining us as a paying member. In addition to the full version of TMD each day, you’ll get extra editions of French Press, the G-FileVital Interests, and our other paid products. And members can engage with the authors and with one another in the discussion threads at the end of each of our articles and newsletters. If this appeals to you, we hope you’ll please join now.

Quick Hits: Today’s Top Stories

  • As of Thursday night, 3,112,252 cases of COVID-19 have been reported in the United States (an increase of 57,602 from yesterday) and 133,228 deaths have been attributed to the virus (an increase of 930 from yesterday), according to the Johns Hopkins University COVID-19 Dashboard, leading to a mortality rate among confirmed cases of 4.3 percent (the true mortality rate is likely much lower, between 0.4 percent and 1.4 percent, but it’s impossible to determine precisely due to incomplete testing regimens). Of 38,032,966 coronavirus tests conducted in the United States (601,300 conducted since yesterday), 8.2 percent have come back positive.

  • On the final day of the term, the Supreme Court ruled 5-4 that, based on 19th-century land treaties, a large part of the state of Oklahoma is actually within a Native American reservation. The court also issued two rulings related to President Trump’s financial records, sending both cases back to the lower courts to decide whether House Democrats or the Manhattan district attorney are entitled to the records. Neither case is now expected to be resolved before the November election.
  • The number of Americans filing initial unemployment insurance claims fell by 99,000 week-over-week to 1.3 million last week. It was the 16th straight week more than 1 million Americans filed initial claims. The total number of Americans receiving unemployment benefits during the week ending on June 27 fell by 698,000 to 18.1 million.
  • New CEO of the U.S. Agency for Global Media Michael Pack is planning to deny visa extensions for dozens of foreign journalists working in the United States for Voice of America. A former board member of the agency called the decision “horrible,” adding that many of the journalists are likely to face “severe” repercussions if they return to their home countries after working for the U.S.
  • Former U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of New York Geoffrey Berman testified before the House Judiciary Committee yesterday behind closed doors, reportedly telling lawmakers Attorney General William Barr urged him to accept another job overseeing the Justice Department’s Civil Division. Berman allegedly said he told Barr “there were important investigations in the Office that I wanted to see through to completion.”
  • The Trump administration appears to be walking back earlier threats to withhold federal funding from schools that do not fully reopen. “We are not suggesting pulling funding from education,” Education Secretary Betsy DeVos said Thursday morning, “but instead allowing families, take that money and figure out where their kids can get educated if their schools refuse to open.”
  • In a speech in Pennsylvania on Thursday, Joe Biden laid out a populist and nationalist economic vision for his potential presidency. Biden’s “Build Back Better” plan would, according to a press release, “ensure that the future is made in America” and “build a modern infrastructure and an equitable, clean energy future.”
  • The Treasury Department sanctioned one Chinese government entity and four Chinese government officials yesterday for their involvement in “serious rights abuses against ethnic minorities in the Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region.”
  • In response to China’s new national security law in Hong Kong, Australian Prime Minister Scott Morrison announced that his country was suspending its extradition treaty with Hong Kong and extending visas for Hong Kong residents.
  • The Big Ten announced Thursday its teams will move to a conference-only schedule for all fall sports, including football, so that the conference can maintain “flexibility to adjust its own operations … and make quick decisions in real-time.”

The End of the SCOTUS Term

In perhaps the most highly anticipated decisions of the season, the Supreme Court was set to decide whether Trump must turn over his financial records to Congress and the New York County District Attorney’s grand jury. In the end, the court sent both cases back to the district court for further arguments, which means Trump won’t be turning over his financial records anytime soon—if he ever does.

Both sides were able to claim some partial victories. The court rejected the arguments from Trump’s attorneys that the president enjoys “absolute immunity from state criminal subpoenas because compliance with those subpoenas would categorically impair a President’s performance of his Article II functions.” But it also also dismissed House Democrats’ arguments, finding that their “approach fails to take adequate account of the significant separation of powers issues raised by congressional subpoenas for the President’s information.”

A constitutional law professor helped break it all down for us. “The court held that Trump was wrong and that [state prosecutors] can request [the president’s personal records], but there might be reasons to withhold them in certain cases,” said Josh Blackman of the South Texas College of Law. “So instead of having this sort of 100 percent prohibition, we’ll consider each request from the states on a case by case basis.”

When the Fringe Goes Mainstream

Does the Republican Party have a QAnon problem? Or a conspiracy problem more generally? In a partisan political climate that has sown the seeds for fringe candidates to win elections, the GOP is struggling to distance itself from conspiracy-mongering nominees without surrendering key districts to Democratic opponents. And sometimes choosing not to distance itself at all.

Audrey Fahlberg profiles a handful of candidates who believe in QAnon or other fringe theories, some of whom could end up in Congress next January.

Back in 2016, “Pizzagate” gained national attention when a man who believed that Hillary Clinton and John Podesta were running a child-trafficking ring out of the Comet Ping Pong pizza restaurant in Washington, D.C., went into the establishment and fired a rifle.

No one was hurt, and the outlandish claims were quickly debunked. But the vile conspiracy theory didn’t totally die. It lingered in dark corners of the internet. And in 2017, an anonymous user named Q—self-dubbed for his alleged Q level security clearance—took the reins and began posting claims that Clinton would be arrested, adding other allegedly classified intel about her on a public messaging board called “4chan.” Mesmerized by Q’s cryptic clues (which were, in reality, baseless rumors), anonymous users began obsessively tracking his posts and the QAnon movement took hold.

QAnon support is rare—a Pew Research poll from March 2020 found only 3 percent of Americans know “a lot” about the theory while 76 percent know “nothing at all”—but those who do support it are deeply invested.

And some of those 3 percent are running for Congress.

GOP primary candidates Lauren Boebert, Marjorie Greene and Jo Rae Perkins have won the hearts of Republican voters in their states. While Perkins secured a Senate primary victory in Oregon and Boebert ousted a Trump-backed incumbent in Colorado’s 3rd District primary, Greene is well on her way to win a House GOP primary runoff in Georgia.

QAnon’s Oregon contender, Jo Rae Perkins, has no realistic shot at beating her Democratic incumbent, Sen. Jeff Merkley. But she won nearly 200,000 votes in her GOP primary—earning almost 50 percent of the vote in a four-person race—and she has garnered national headlines for some of her bolder proclamations. Lauren Boebert and Marjorie Greene, however, have a real chance at winning the general election in each of their districts.

Worth Your Time

  • If you looked at the COVID charts in any recent TMD, you will notice a widening gulf between the trend in new cases and the trend in daily deaths. The Atlantic’s Derek Thompson wrote quite possibly the best piece we’ve read on the subject, explaining what we know about this divergence—and what we don’t. “In the fog of pandemic, every statistic tells a story, but no one statistic tells the whole truth.”
  • Brad Polumbo wrote a piece for the Foundation for Economic Education that zeroes in on two Joe Biden policy positions—his support for AB 5 in California and his desire to repeal Section 230—that could dramatically damage the economic landscape for millions of Americans. President Trump has signaled a desire to limit Section 230 protections for tech companies as well, but AB 5, if nationalized, could essentially eliminate independent-contracting as we know it today. “From artists to musicians to freelance journalists to Uber drivers, thousands of California workers saw their livelihoods snuffed out by this bill,” Brad writes. “Even the original sponsor of the law, state Assemblywoman Lorena Gonzalez, admitted she was ‘wrong’ in response to angry freelancers who lost work.”
  • Atlanta rapper Michael Render—Killer Mike—went viral last month for a speech he gave during the protests that erupted in the aftermath of George Floyd’s death. But that moment was far from his first foray into politics. Donovan Ramsey went to Atlanta to profile Render for GQ, and came back fascinated by the contradictions. Killer Mike “is a proud ‘compassionate capitalist,’” Ramsey writes. “A small-business owner and landlord with multiple barbershops, a restaurant, and about $2 million in property across Atlanta. But he’s also backed democratic socialist candidates like Bernie Sanders, who, Mike has said, operates in the spirit of Martin Luther King Jr.”

Presented Without Comment

Berny Belvedere @bernybelvedere

Okay, so, what we have here is a white group who changed their name in a bid to convey solidarity with the black community … now suing a black female blues singer in order to secure exclusive usage of the new name. Hooboy. https://t.co/hXx733Xg5e

The Hollywood Reporter @THR

Lady A, formerly known as Lady Antebellum, files lawsuit against blues singer Anita White who goes by the name Lady A https://t.co/vjA0ySmCpb

Toeing the Company Line

  • David and Sarah are going to need a breather after all these emergency pods. But they managed to muster one more episode of Advisory Opinions this week, and you’re not going to want to miss it. The duo talked about how many in the media misinterpreted the court’s decisions on Trump’s financial records.
  • This was a good week for small-L liberalism, David writes in his most recent French Press (🔒). An open letter published in Harper’s Magazine set the internet ablaze earlier this week. Even though some of its signatories have “hardly been stalwart defenders of free speech (especially from conservatives) in the past,” David argues the fact that so many are seeing the light now is a very positive development. “The cynic responds, ‘Oh, so now they’re worried, when their ox is finally gored.’ The better response is to say, ‘Welcome to the struggle, friend. This is exactly how things change.’”
  • On the site today, Andrew explains the state of play on COVID testing, and he notes the strain on the system. “First, there’s the test positivity rate, which tracks what percentage of COVID tests come back positive and thus helps us gauge the strength of our testing apparatus relative to the strength of the virus. Second, there’s the test turnaround time, which gives a sense of how backlogged the labs processing the tests are getting.”

Reporting by Declan Garvey (@declanpgarvey), Andrew Egger (@EggerDC), Sarah Isgur (@whignewtons), Charlotte Lawson (@charlotteUVA), Audrey Fahlberg (@FahlOutBerg), Nate Hochman (@njhochman), and Steve Hayes (@stephenfhayes).

Photograph by Alex Wong/Getty Images.