The Morning Dispatch: Police Reform Hits a Partisan Wall

Plus, more on masking and the states that require it.

Happy Thursday! In the words of Sen. Marco Rubio, “Everyone should just wear a damn mask.”

A reminder: This is the version of TMD available to non-paying readers. We’re happy you’ve made The Dispatch part of your morning routine, and we hope you’re enjoying The Morning Dispatch and the rest of our free editorial offerings. If you do, we hope you’ll consider joining us as a paying member. In addition to the full version of TMD each day, you’ll get extra editions of French Press, the G-FileVital Interests, and our other paid products. And members can engage with the authors and with one another in the discussion threads at the end of each of our articles and newsletters. If this appeals to you, we hope you’ll please join now.

Quick Hits: Today’s Top Stories

  • As of Wednesday night, 2,380,490 cases of COVID-19 have been reported in the United States (an increase of 33,553 from yesterday) and 121,969 deaths have been attributed to the virus (an increase of 745 from yesterday), according to the Johns Hopkins University COVID-19 Dashboard, leading to a mortality rate among confirmed cases of 5.1 percent (the true mortality rate is likely much lower, between 0.4 percent and 1.4 percent, but it’s impossible to determine precisely due to incomplete testing regimens). Of 28,567,355 coronavirus tests conducted in the United States (502,290 conducted since yesterday), 8.3 percent have come back positive.

  • A federal appeals court panel ordered a dismissal of the case against Michael Flynn, President Trump’s former national security adviser. The president told reporters that news of the dismissal made him “very happy,” adding: “He’s been exonerated. I want to congratulate him.”
  • The three men charged with killing Ahmaud Arbery were officially indicted on nine counts, including felony murder, by a Georgia grand jury. “This is another step forward in seeking justice for Ahmaud,” the local District Attorney said in a statement.
  • Senate Democrats blocked the GOP police reform bill spearheaded by South Carolina Sen. Tim Scott, justifying their move to prevent the legislation from reaching the 60 votes needed to advance to debate by arguing the JUSTICE Act did not go far enough in addressing issues of racial justice and police brutality.
  • The Senate’s Wednesday confirmation of Cory Wilson to a New Orleans circuit court marks the 200th judge installed by the Trump administration, working in concert with Mitch McConnell’s Republican Senate majority.
  • The federal government is reportedly planning to end federal funding for 13 different coronavirus testing sites, spread out across five different states, on June 30, shifting operations to states. Coronavirus testing czar Brett Giroir said, “We are transitioning 13 sites from the original now antiquated program to the more efficient and effective testing sites.”

‘The Actual Problem is Not What is Being Offered. It is Who is Offering It.’

On June 1, Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer said: “Leader McConnell should commit to put a law enforcement reform bill on the floor of the Senate before July 4.” A week later, McConnell announced that he had tasked Sen. Tim Scott with leading a working group to craft exactly that. Their legislation, the JUSTICE Act, was introduced in the Senate this week, and on Wednesday, Democrats blocked it from advancing to debate.

All 52 Republicans—and three dissidents from the Democratic caucus—voted to advance the police reform package, but the legislation fell short of the 60 votes necessary.

The JUSTICE Act—as we detailed in last Thursday’s Morning Dispatch—would require local police departments report to the FBI any use of force that results in death or serious injury, withhold federal funding from states and law enforcement agencies that do not ban the use of chokeholds except in “situations where deadly force is authorized,” subsidize the purchase of body cameras and relevant training for state and local governments, and make lynching a federal crime.

Making Masking Mandatory

Washington Gov. Jay Inslee rolled out an order requiring his constituents to wear masks in all indoor public areas and in outdoor public areas where social distancing cannot be maintained. The rule will go into effect Friday, adding Washington to a list of nearly 20 other states with mandatory face mask orders—including four that have been hit hardest by coronavirus: New York, California, New Jersey, and Illinois.

Statewide mask orders typically follow major spikes in new COVID-19 cases and hospitalizations, and people are more likely to adhere to these mandates in areas most affected by the virus. A recent Pew Research Center poll found 80 percent of adults in counties with a high COVID-19 death rate reported wearing a mask in stores or businesses all or most of the time, compared to 55 percent of adults in counties with a low death rate.

The same survey also uncovered stark divisions in mask wearing based on political affiliation, race, and age. Among Democrats, 76 percent reported wearing masks all or most of the time, while only 53 percent of Republicans did. (Geography is likely a confounding variable here, with Democrats more likely than Republicans to live in urban environments.) Asian adults—at 80 percent—were the most likely to acknowledge wearing masks all or most of the time, while white adults—at 62 percent—were the least. Among Americans 65 and older—a group considered high risk—74 percent reported wearing masks all or most of the time, compared with 61 percent of adults between the ages of 30 and 49.

Worth Your Time

  • Should Confederate statues be toppled down, or should they be left alone and preserved for history’s sake? According to Joshua Zeitz, the answer is obvious when you look at post-WWII Germany. “When armies are defeated on their own soil—particularly when those armies fight to promote racist or genocidal policies—they usually don’t get to keep their symbols and material culture,” he wrote in August 2017 in the wake of Charlottesville’s Unite the Right rally. Though this article was written three years ago, its message still resonates today.
  • Robert Julian-Borchak Williams spent 30 hours behind bars for a crime he didn’t commit. Why? Police officers wrongfully arrested him after a flawed match in their department’s facial recognition algorithm. Law enforcement agencies have been using facial recognition technology to help solve crimes for several years now, and studies show the systems falsely identify black and Asian faces 10 to 100 times more often than white faces. Read Kashmir Hill’s New York Times piece, which tells the heartbreaking story of a man who was permanently scarred by a flaw in the criminal justice system.
  • Bernie Sanders had his moments along the way to losing the Democratic nomination in both 2016 and 2020, but he’s become less relevant in the midst of this cultural moment when democratic socialism has been supplanted by a more cultural reckoning. “Rather than Medicare for All and taxing plutocrats, the rallying cry is racial justice and defunding the police,” writes Ross Douthat in his New York Times column earlier this week.

Presented Without Comment, Throwback Edition

Toeing the Company Line

  • Jonah’s Wednesday G-File (🔒) takes issue with some of the statue toppling we’ve seen in recent weeks, as crowds have gone after not just Confederate monuments but also statues of U.S. Grant and, in Madison, Wisconsin, an immigrant abolitionist named Hans Christian Heg. “People try to defend it, to give it context, to make it more sophisticated and high-minded,” he writes. “They say ‘You don’t understand, they’re angry.’ Who doesn’t understand that? It’s not a difficult concept to grasp. But if anger is self-justifying, then anything can be destroyed.”
  • You may have noticed, we’ve been having some technical difficulties with our podcast feeds in recent days as we update our hosting platform. Our apologies for the inconvenience, but we do have a new Remnant for you over at the site. Jonah was joined by a returning guest, Fox News’ Chris Stirewalt, to discuss Teddy Roosevelt’s legacy and 1800s newspapers, as well as offering some rank punditry.
  • In the latest Vital Interests (🔒), Thomas Joscelyn explores the disconnect between President Trump’s messaging about ending “endless wars” and the number of strikes we’ve made against al-Qaeda. Joscelyn critiques how in a speech “the president cavalierly dismissed the wars in Afghanistan and elsewhere as ‘ancient conflicts in faraway lands that many people have never even heard of.’”
  • The pandemic disrupted an already struggling agricultural sector by disrupting supply chains. Blake Hurst looks at how it also exposed deeper problems between ranchers and meat processing companies, and he warns that some of the proposed solutions might be repeats of past mistakes.

Reporting by Declan Garvey (@declanpgarvey), Andrew Egger (@EggerDC), Sarah Isgur (@whignewtons), Charlotte Lawson (@charlotteUVA), Audrey Fahlberg (@FahlOutBerg), Nate Hochman (@njhochman), and Steve Hayes (@stephenfhayes).